A tube allows controlled dispensing of certain care products, a jar allows product to be taken directly, a pump bottle makes many liquid uses easier and an airless system can meet particular dispensing and protection needs. No solution is better in principle. Constraints of viscosity, hygiene, premium perception, filling and cost must be considered together.

Comparison by product type

A thick cream can be hard to dispense with certain pumps; a very fluid serum may require a precise device to limit losses; a scrub containing particles may need a wider opening. The choice must be tested against the real formula. The residual quantity that cannot be dispensed, stability and how well the container holds up during transport must also be checked.

The real cost is not limited to the empty container

Add the cap or pump, the label, any carton, filling time, losses, component minimum order quantities and the management of returns. A system that is cheaper to buy can make production more complex. The final decision should bring together purchasing, production, formulation, marketing and regulatory affairs, ideally around a physical sample.

Tool: a selection table by product family with level of protection, dosing, ease of filling and full cost.

Points to approve in your file

For each of the following elements, write down the decision taken, the person who approves it and the document that can justify it:

  • Viscosity.
  • Protection.
  • Dosing.
  • Filling.
  • Costs.
  • Losses.
Examples of cosmetic formats with a pipette and jars

Frequently asked question

Is airless packaging always preferable to a pipette?

No. The answer depends on the formula, the protection required, the viscosity, the dosing, the cost and the expected experience. The device must be validated with the real product.

Apply this guide to your project

To apply this guide, document two elements first: the viscosity and the protection. If an industrial study is needed, specify the products, indicative volumes, packaging and countries of sale concerned. The BIOCYLAB team can examine this information according to the actual scope of the project; quantities, lead times and services must be confirmed before any decision.

Reference sources

Request a quote