Testing a cream only on the first impression of its scent or its feel on the finger leaves out important criteria. Before the prototype, define the objective of the product: target, use, texture, appearance, absorption, fragrance, ease of rinsing or behaviour under makeup. Written approval criteria make feedback more usable for the formulator and limit contradictory changes.

Organise the comparison between versions

Give each sample a code, a date and a brief version. Compare the prototypes under conditions that are as constant as possible and record the observations separately: visual, odour, application, delayed feel and intended packaging. Feedback from friends and family can help explore preferences, but it does not replace a formal usage study or the tests needed for safety or stability.

From preference to industrial decision

A formula can be appealing in a short test and then prove difficult to fill, unstable or incompatible with its container. Before final approval, ask which criteria have been checked in the laboratory and which remain open. Marketing approval of the feel does not mean regulatory approval of the finished product. Formalise the acceptance of a version and stop the multiplication of variants once the essential criteria are met.

Useful aid: a prototype test sheet with an identifier, scored criteria, comments, the decision and explicit requests for changes.

Dropper bottle surrounded by small dishes

Points to approve in your file

For each of the following elements, write down the decision taken, the person who approves it and the document that can justify it:

  • Sample version.
  • Test method.
  • Criteria.
  • Observations.
  • Changes.
  • Decision.

Frequently asked question

How many prototypes need to be approved?

There is no universal number. The number of iterations depends on the brief, the formulation difficulties and the criteria actually established. The most important thing is to compare identified versions and avoid changes without a measurable objective.

Apply this guide to your project

To apply this guide, document two elements first: the sample version and the test method. If an industrial study is needed, specify the products, indicative volumes, packaging and countries of sale concerned. The BIOCYLAB team can examine this information according to the actual scope of the project; quantities, lead times and services must be confirmed before any decision.

Request a quote