“I want to create a natural cream, how much does it cost?” does not make it possible to compare two industrial answers. The laboratory needs to know the use, the target, the desired texture, the intended claims, the country of sale, the packaging, the number of products and the quantities. Without these parameters, one quote may exclude formulation, tests, boxes or the regulatory file, while another includes them.

Compare quotes on an identical scope

Create a grid with separate lines: development, samples, tests, materials, manufacturing, filling, primary components, labels, secondary packaging, controls, documentation, transport and any taxes. For each item, note “included”, “optional” or “not specified”. Then ask for the unit cost delivered at the same logistics stage, with the same volumes and the same specifications. Comparing only the price of the bottle can lead you to choose an offer that ends up costing more.

The questions that avoid overruns

Who approves the label texts? How many prototype revision cycles are included? Who buys the components? How is a change of formula handled contractually? When is the print proof frozen? Which documents will be delivered? And what amount must be paid before production? These questions must receive written, understandable answers before signing.

Tool offered to the reader: a brief template with one line per product and a grid for analysing quotes. The commercial form only comes after this method has been provided.

Template for comparing two offers

Comparison question Manufacturer A Manufacturer B
Formula version and number of products To be completed To be completed
Quantity per product To be completed To be completed
Prototypes and changes included To be completed To be completed
Studies and documents included To be completed To be completed
Primary and secondary packaging To be completed To be completed
Controls and batch identification To be completed To be completed
Transport, delivery and payment terms To be completed To be completed

Writing “not specified” rather than assuming that an item is included is already a significant improvement. Send this same grid to both manufacturers with an identical brief; ask for a written answer on the differences in scope. If the formula, the format or the volume changes during the negotiation, the previous comparison must be updated. A useful quote is not the one with the most figures, but the one whose assumptions can be verified.

Blue branded box on a lab bench

Points to approve in your file

For each of the following elements, write down the decision taken, the person who approves it and the document that can justify it:

  • Scope included.
  • Variants.
  • Controls.
  • Files.
  • Transport.
  • Payment schedule.

Frequently asked question

Why do two quotes with the same unit price remain different?

They may include different scopes: tests, box, labels, formulation, transport or documentary support. Compare the fixed costs and the excluded services before ranking the suppliers.

Apply this guide to your project

To apply this guide, document two elements first: the scope included and the variants. If an industrial study is needed, specify the products, indicative volumes, packaging and countries of sale concerned. The BIOCYLAB team can examine this information according to the actual scope of the project; quantities, lead times and services must be confirmed before any decision.

Request a quote